Should Trees be Forever?

I have a confession to make.  About three years ago, I took out the eastern red cedar in my front yard. I know many people feel that taking down any tree is an immoral act. Some would point out that when you cut down a tree, the decomposing wood releases carbon into the atmosphere. Also, you are removing wildlife food and habitat – and eastern red cedar is supposed to be one of the highest value trees for wildlife.

But I don’t care! I’d do it again, I tell you! I hated that tree. It deserved to die. First of all, it was ugly. Second, it took up a lot of space and created a wide barren zone under its drip line. But worst of all were the prickles. They were sharp! They were constantly being shed over a wide area, so walking barefoot in the front yard was a truly painful experience. Not to mention how they would get in your hair, etc.

Still standing: my neighbors' cedar to the left of our house. The one we had was to the right, on the other side of the driveway.

Plus, it’s not as if there were a shortage of eastern red cedar. When the houses on our block were built, the developer planted one in every front yard, and just about all are still there, along with the silver maples and siberian elms in the backyards.

What’s more, I made amends. Where the red cedar stood, I planted a “Donald Wyman” crabapple. Crabapples also have high wildlife value, don’t they? Well, don’t they? What do you mean, I sound defensive?

I admit, I can’t help feeling I have committed a sin. That I am morally obligated to live with a tree I don’t want, like two people in a loveless marriage, until one of us croaks. But don’t I have a right to happiness? Must I be prevented from trying to grow the yard of my dreams?

Now I’m having conflicted feelings about a big old bridalwreath in the back yard. I want to get rid of it and plant a pagoda dogwood in its place. But guilt holds me back. The bridal wreath is just a shrub, and still it feels wrong to get rid of it. Will I ever be free to garden without guilt?

What I would like our Donald Wyman crab to look like. Ours is nice, but not this nice.

4 Comments on “Should Trees be Forever?

  1. I have a sentimental spot in my heart for Eastern Redcedar. Mainly because it is a signature tree of the native landscape around here, will grow where few other trees will, they are very salt tolerant and they live along time. That said, I am sure I wouldn’t want one in my front yard.

  2. I’ve gotten past the point of feeling guilt at cutting down trees and shrubs. Moving into our current house cured me of that. Our yard was so overgrown that it took us nine pickup loads just to haul all the refuse off.

    Still, a project to cut something down will probably be set aside in order to get something new in the ground — unless of course, the something new needs that exact spot . . .

  3. i’ve pretty much decided to get rid of the bridalwreath. I’m going to replace it with a flowering dogwood from ForestFarm. You’re in the northwest, right? Have you ever visited their place in Oregon?

  4. Guilt comes with chopping trees down when their in public, and are landmarks around the area. Otherwise, if its invading on my life style such as your’s was, I see no problem and I put on the biggest grin possible to protect my self from feeling anything. Besides, who doesn’t enjoy bringing a tree down and screaming TIMMMMMMMMMMMBERRRRRRRRR!!! Hahahahahaha

    -Tony Salmeron

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: